94 Comments
User's avatar
TnDoc's avatar
1dEdited

Excellent post, Scott. Thanks for sharing.

As I am about to complete my 76th trip around the Sun, I have come to realize that most of what we are taught by our Programmers here in the US was and is a series of endless lies to perpetuate the myth of Amerikan Exceptionalism. The lies revolve around the nation's duplicitous commitment to liberty, equality, freedom, "democracy", ad nauseum. Certainly within my lifetime, we have been at continuous war (all unconstitutional by our own law and illegal by international laws and treaties). The facts of the matter are that we are "exceptional" only in that we are particularly adept at oppressing people (especially non-white people) all around the planet and looting anyone and everyone that resides outside of the US. As Empires collapse in their death throes, their criminality is turned inward upon itself. We are there. The karmic chickens are a'roosting...

Anthony Dunn's avatar

I should have also thanked Scott for such a moving piece.

Anthony Aguilar's testimony - pasted in below - on current settler colonialism adds to the poignancy of what Scott writes here; and how good and decent people are fooled into doing evil things without realising when they're young and how the few brave ones do speak out or at the very least resign in disgust when they realise what they are actually doing:

https://substack.com/inbox/post/184951746

No doubt many of you are already aware of this former US officer.

Thanks for being so brave, Scott and I'm very sorry to hear about the freezing of your bank account and the constant harassment you receive for you goodness and courage.

Wolfgang Exel Watson's avatar

People could raise hell for their "representatives" to pass a law that forbids limitations in the US mail service to send cash via certified mail. That way, Scott could receive supporting letters with cash to help with the "banklessness". However, we would actually all be better off without banks. Banks are the masters to whom everybody else can only be a slave.

Aspergers UK's avatar

Great article Scott. My blood boiled when I read of the traitors who helped track down their native brothers.

Listen, my brother, the America you seek is called Russia. I hope you find your home there soon. Peace big man.

Ranger1221regnaR's avatar

Amen with that also Aspergers UK - and also from the UK - likely Asperger's too. I wish I could go to Russia and stay there.

Daddy Ron's avatar

Dang Scott, this one hurt. I was just getting over your earlier post concerning your relationship with your father. I'm 82 years old and passed through the Vietnam war. I shared your post with my son and I passed on my old box of books and talked with my son. My memory still pretty good. That one hurt a little bit. But now as I read your post this morning it hurt even more. My son and I live in Flagstaff. My daughter-in-law works for the Park service in the Grand canyon and my son is a riverboatman with well over a hundred trips down the Colorado River. I have been in and out of Arizona since 1978 and I'm well aware of the Navajo and Hopi plight. I was stationed at Amarillo Air Force Base during the Cuban missile crisis and spend a lot of time down in Palo duro canyon. I was stationed in North Carolina and became well acquainted with the Trail of Tears. I was stationed at Dover Air Force Base in the early sixties when we were christened, THE MORGUE. This post really hurts Scott. But I thank you for reminding me that Mr Trump's mountain of Bull Shit about MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN, is that I have been lied to all my life. Thank you my brother.

Daddy Ron's avatar

And oh by the way Scott, another of your recent post is really getting into some of my past locked doors. Your post on 35 years anniversary of Desert Storm. Well 35 years ago my army reserve 70th division unit was activated. They gave us Christmas Eve with our family and on Christmas morning we were on our way to Fort Benning. Son, you need to quit reading my mail.

Dale Casto's avatar

To add the hypocrisy, the US is planning to conquer this defenseless island in preparation for war with Russia (for coming to the aid of the Ethnic Russians in the Ukraine after the US overthrew the democracy in 2014) and China.

We were also planning to kill even more Iranians to reinstate the son of the dictator we put in place after we overthrew that democracy. But to be fair, that was on orders of our overlords. The attack was postponed when out supreme commander, Netanyahu, decided the time was not right.

JohnOnKaui's avatar

FWIW: Rumors are TACO on bombing Iran. It seems the Iranian threat to US bases in the Persian gulf is indefensible.

Just a rumor though.

I can tell you that there are a lot of KC-46 sorties flying out of St. Croix, so the threat to Venezuela is on-going.

Jim O'Donnell's avatar

(Charlie Chaplin)... 'I am an individual and a believer in liberty.'

In response to journalists for comments on United States Attorney-General’s announcement to revoke his re-entry visa, September 23, 1952 (quoted in The Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/century/1950-1959/Story/0,,105162,00.html): “I am not a political man and I have no political convictions. I am an individual and a believer in liberty. That is all the politics I have. On the other hand I am not a super-patriot. Super -patriotism leads to Hitlerism - and we’ve had our lesson there. I don’t want to create a revolution - I just want to create a few more films.”

Jacobite's avatar

Super-patriotism leads to Hitlerism? Sorry Charlie, but Hitlerism was super-patriotism (German patriotism), and this inexorably led to bad feelings towards the anti-Germans in Germany. Don't forget, as a de-mobbed soldier, Hitler watched in person the March, 1919, KPD and Spartacist uprising in Munich. Led by three Jewish Bolsheviks (Levien, Levin, and Axelrod), the Communists were responsible for over 800 deaths, slaughtered innocent hostages (some things never change), and wrecked the center of the city. The police and Reichswehr were aided in the final righteous assault by hundreds of citizen volunteers raised by the mayor (anti-Semites to a man, by definition). Fascinating to observe the workings of the MENA mind -- super-patriotism is evil, except when it's Israeli super-patriotism. A German Germany or English England is an abomination, but Israel as a Jewish state is Yahweh-ordained wonderfulness. Genocide is evil except when it's in Gaza, or the Red Terror, or the Holomodor. or the Diaspora Uprising of 115-117 A.D.

JohnOnKaui's avatar

This is America.

Aaron Good explains that this has been America since the Pilgrims landed on Plymouth Rock. Boomers don't know this because after WWII and the Soviet launch of Sputnik, American Leadership panicked and committed huge amounts to providing education to the Boomers as well as subsidizing mortgages for the WWII veterans who where the Boomers parents.

The Oligarchy was in retreat and scared

They are not scared any longer. The return of the Oligarchy has many points in history that could be labeled as "the beginning of the return". One of them is the 1971 "Powell Memo" which outlined how the Oligarchy could combat "attacks on capitalism".

As a Boomer who graduated in 1969, I can attest that the deterioration of American Education was already in progress. The outstanding instructors I had in elementary school and up to the 9th grade began leaving to be replaced by "second string" wannabes. Some great teachers remained but the tide of dummies was insurmountable. One of the best was fired because she was too good. Look up American Literacy then compare it to China and Russia. The Oligarchy thrives on stupid. They have turned on America and are doing to every American what they did to the Native Americans.

The Oligarchy wants to kill you, just as they murdered Renee Good who was sending her son to a Charter School which provided a superior education -- not a Christian or Jewish or Ukrainian Indoctrination Camp. ICE is now targeting the school.

https://sahanjournal.com/education/minneapolis-southside-family-charter-school-threats/

RonaldB's avatar

The article you cited made no mention of ICE targeting the school. Try being more accurate in your reporting.

JohnOnKaui's avatar

What, are you one of those who believes that Putin woke up one day and decided to invade Ukraine for no reason at all.

Would you have been happier with "MAGA is targeting the school"?

"“I’m calling for all federal funds to Minnesota’s Southside Family Charter School to be REVOKED,” Rep. Buddy Carter, R-Ga., wrote on Facebook. “This institution radicalizes students and pushes a left-wing agenda that demonizes ICE agents. The federal government should not subsidize anti-American education.”"

Don't keep your head in the sand.

RonaldB's avatar

You said ICE was targeting the school and cited an article to support your assertion. I pointed out the article made no such assertion. From that factual statement, you're asserting I think Putin woke up one day and decided to invade Ukraine for no reason.

I do think you ought to try to distinguish reality from fantasies. Try it sometime, You may even like it.

JohnOnKaui's avatar

I did, and they are. Do you not know where Renee Good was murdered?

-I- am the one asserting that ICE is targeting the school. -I- am saying "water is wet".

You are the one denying the reality of ICE and the Fascism coming to America. You are picking at nits. You seem to be unaware of the attacks on education all around the country. You don't know what is happening in Minnesota. You are living in a fantasy land off denial.

RonaldB's avatar

You're sounding like a Bot to me. All I said was the article you cited to support your statement didn't support your statement. You're giving me all kinds of emotional twitches because you don't like me holding you to a clear statement of fact. If you think that ICE is targeting the school because your emotions are telling you that, I have no objection. I only object when you cite a factual source for your assertion which doesn't support the assertion. I actually made no statement at all on the other issues you emoted on. I didn't even defend ICE. I just said your statement of fact was not supported by your reference. If you want to attack ICE, then find an article that says what you say it says.

JohnOnKaui's avatar

You are sounding stupid to me.

“All I did was make a stupid, inane, comment that would prove to the world that I’m smarter than JohnOnKaui”

Keep it up dummy. You should have known before you posted what my reaction was going to be. You want to keep up this exchange, I’ll go all fucking day.

Clarke Fountain's avatar

A powerful essay. It may or may not be "human nature" for these things to happen, and records show the native peoples were not universally better behaved in some respects with regards to each other or the encroaching white man, but evil is evil and it is our obligation to resist it.

Despite laws to the contrary, active suppression of native American religions still goes on. Nobody wants a Sundance ceremony on their unused farmlands, for instance, so they NIMBY and regulate against it (you've got to have a permit to have religious activity here, etc.). They happen anyway, though. I knew some Ojibway who never took BIA status because they didn't want to be regulated the way the BIA does it. Strong people. Still around.

Dorothy's avatar

Amazing essay. America has been toxic since before it was founded.

Gil Raviv's avatar

Thank you so much Scott for reminding us of what is true and what is precious!

Pete Comwest's avatar

"nation they have repeatedly defended in time of war"

What fighting in Vietnam or elsewhere has to do with 'defending' America ?

JohnOnKaui's avatar

It is the nature of British/American capitalism to prod and push and subvert and bribe and cajole until the target gives up or reacts violently. Brian Berletic has tons of YouTube videos that explain the US "continuity of agenda". It does not matter who is President. If "they" (the "Deep State": which is an extremely poor label but better than "elites". The "conspiracy against America" is so broad that only Aaron Good can explain it, and he admits there's no label adequate) don't like what you are doing, you will be removed from office.

Look for Aaron Good and Max Arvo's review of the movie "All the President's Men" where they speculate that Watergate was a clandestine operation to remove Nixon from office because he was pursuing detente with Russia. It is a compelling argument. (I know it is on Patreon. I can't find it elsewhere.)

Several individuals have explained the "limited hangout" off scandals during the GHWB administration, because he didn't go all the way to Baghdad, which resulted in Clinton being placed in office where Mossad agent Monica was able to monitor him.

The "Deep State" is turning on America now. They have lost in Ukraine. They may have to abandon Israel. It is "us or them" time.

Ranger1221regnaR's avatar

Well, put, and your conclusion "it is "us or them" time" is spot on. It really is time.

larry, dfh's avatar

Thank you very much for your Travelogue, with its extensively researched historical background! This should be in all school curricula. Along with the millions of lives that have been lost, is the knowledge those peoples developed in how to survive with minimal environmental destruction. Looking at the agricultural contributions of western Native civilizations one realizes that their contributions feed much of the world. Not to mention their engineering expertise: Machu Picchu walls still stand after 500 years in an active fault zone, extensive canals in the Amazon Basin, etc. Thanks for your empathy! BTW, as you probably saw, the best sight of the Grand Canyon, if you're in the right place, is RIGHT BEFORE the sun breaches the cliff walls. Spectacular!

Imam Faisal's avatar

Thank you Mr. Ritter for this brilliant article. We appreciate that you cut through the propaganda and show us the true history of what can only be described as European colonization. Everything you mentioned also happened in India, Algeria, Libya, the Middle East, east Asia, and it is happening currently in Palestine. The elephant in the room is that religious figures and language are often invoked to justify these invasions. White man's burden, Christian zionism, Eurocentrism, and now Musk's defense of the white race, are misused to justify killing. The conflict with Russia also has its origins in Western European exceptionalism. The Qu'ran states: "O mankind, We have created you from male and female, nations and tribes, that you know one another. Indeed the most noble of you in the sight of God is the one with the most piety." You are a true patriot Scott, and more importantly, a true human being.

Roland's avatar

J D Vance went to Greenland and told them: “We’ll treat you well”. So they are just to submit to American writ? What utter arrogance.

Here in Britain to try to save what remains of world order we should put retaliatory tariffs on all US goods including techno-feudal contracts - and barely even mention doing it. But it would not surprise me to find that Whitehall wants a piece of the Greenland pie as well. At least the Prime minister has said he holds with Greenland and Denmark.

Well, as Max Manus, the oddly named Norwegian World War II hero was known to have said, there’s no thrill like attacking a battleship from a canoe.

Ranger1221regnaR's avatar

Indeed it would be a thrill, but I fear that's all it would be. Our little Island has no teeth any more, and even our toothless suck is not enough to pull the skin off porridge.

Roland's avatar

You obviously mean Britain; I had Inuit kayaks more in mind, as I had hoped Britain could avoid fighting both the Americans in Greenland and the Russians in Ukraine (once the alliance has fought to the last Ukrainian and coked-out mercenary). But perhaps Navy Seal snipers will spot them coming and be able to thaw their trigger fingers in time to shoot back.

Ranger1221regnaR's avatar

Indeed I did, but Britain against the USA is pretty much the same deal - it would be a short-lived thrill, but that said, I think the Inuits in Kayaks would last longer :-D

Britain hasn't enough of a Military to even dent Russias Military, even after they've fought to the Last Ukrainian. Taking on both will just speed up our defeat, and no doubt be a laughing stock for centuries.

suzanna grove's avatar

$ can not stave off Karma

Clint Hightower's avatar

The more I dig into the United States history, I understand more as to why we are so aligned with Israel. Likely decedents from the same Europeans. IDF archives reveal much about this time.

I live in Utah, the Mountain Meadow Massacre, took place 20 minutes from where I was borned, raised, and currently reside.

I knew very little about this event until recently, I had always heard of the mountain meadow massacre, yet I never knew the details. No one here talks about it. It is truly horrifying, LDS settlers carried out the same ruthless, and unforgiving acts that equal the savagrie you describe in your article, and we are witnessing in the middle East. I am disgusted, and appaulled by the deceitful banner of a "civilized, free, democracy," that our Empire hides behind.

obe's avatar

IMHO America has been a colonial empire for most, if not all, of its history. First within North America, then South America and the Pacific, and following WW2 the whole world. It does (did?) have the best propaganda machine in known history and has fooled most of us, me included. I have worked for the three letter fifth column thinking I was helping my country in becoming democratic. In reality all we were doing was leveling the field for American corporations and agencies to take over, as they know how to handle democracy to their advantage. My family suffered due to the Soviet occupation and the ensuing communist regim imposed in 1947, but the actions of the US government have made me think the Bolsheviks were maybe not as bad as I thought. All this wouldn't have been apparent without the advent of the Internet and without people like you. This true patriotism.